Baby Carrots
This showed up in my Facebook news feed yesterday. It's not the first time I've heard about chlorine used in baby carrots, though it's one of the better explanations I've heard. I've said it before, I don't always agree with Food Babe, but there are times I do. This is one of those times I agree. The idea of a chlorine bath never sat well with me and I had previously looked in to this issue. I believe my original source was an article in a magazine (yeah, I'll never find that again!). Mercola almost waivers on both sides of this issue and 100 Days of Real Food (which is a source I under use greatly, the whole site is quite good) also called up the company itself.
As each of these sources state, while it is generally considered safe, these are an occasional if at all purchase in my house. Most importantly for carrots is that they are organic. Why? Carrots seem to be middle ground according to EWG's list, they don't make it to the "Dirty Dozen." Carrots are sometimes used to clean toxins in soil - generally when switching from chemical to organic gardening. The idea is they absorb the toxins in the soil. Let that sit for just a moment. Should that work (I first read about this in Pollon's In Defense of Food, I believe) these carrots are laden with the harmful things initially in the soil. Upon further investigation, I believe it is used more often with heavy metals and arsenic - or perhaps that's just where the research is leaning at this point. My mother repeated this idea of carrots as cleaners of soil, she'd heard it from a cooking and gardening course she took at the community college (on a side note, some community colleges are starting to offer fun classes for older people at a reasonable price, check your local one out to see if there's something you're interested in!). I haven't found conclusive evidence that carrots are going to soak up all kinds of evils from the ground and poison you. Looked for it, and if it's available, they're making it hard to find.
Here's my common sense take on this, should carrots be successful in cleaning soil, then they are taking in those contaminates. I don't trust food conglomerates to care about me and not simply sell carrots used for this among all the other carrots (yep, went a little conspiracy theory on you there; but my trust for anyone who is trying to make money off my consumption is low). So, organic makes sense to me. As for the chlorine aspect of baby carrots: we don't all have the luxury of going to a farmer's market to avoid chlorine assisted produce, so I try to take it out where I can. Sure, it's not a lot - it's within guidelines. Some (like Mercola) go on about how guidelines may not be accurate, etc; but my thing is that even if something is within guidelines, which ones accumulate in your body? What amount is "close enough" that inspectors close their eyes, or the corporation/facility simply doesn't care? My choice is to do as much self regulation as possible, which is why we rarely buy baby carrots (we had friends visit so I had four minions running around, baby carrots got snatched up to save time). It's not that hard if you make some containers of cut vegetables yourself to keep them snackable and readily available. So am I going to give you a hard time if I visit and you have baby carrots out? Not at all, I'll be eating them right along with you. Are they always available in my home? No, they are brought in like most convenience foods: sparingly.